Why is Back EMF of BLDC Trapezoidal?
The back EMF (electromotive force) generated in a Brushless DC (BLDC) motor is a crucial factor in its operation. While most people are familiar with the sinusoidal back EMF waveform of a BLDC motor, a less known fact is that a BLDC motor with a trapezoidal commutation scheme generates a trapezoidal back EMF. This article delves into the reasons behind this phenomenon, exploring the relationship between commutation strategies, stator windings, and the resulting back EMF shape.
Understanding Back EMF
Back EMF is a voltage induced in the stator windings of a motor due to the rotation of the rotor. This voltage opposes the applied voltage and is proportional to the motor's speed and magnetic field strength. In a BLDC motor, the back EMF waveform directly reflects the magnetic field distribution within the motor.
Trapezoidal Commutation and Back EMF
Trapezoidal commutation is a simple and cost-effective method for controlling BLDC motors. It uses a switching sequence that keeps two stator phases energized while the third phase is deactivated. This results in a constant magnetic field strength within the motor, creating a trapezoidal back EMF.
How Trapezoidal Commutation Generates Trapezoidal Back EMF:
-
Phase Energization: In trapezoidal commutation, two phases of the stator windings are energized at a time. This creates a magnetic field that is concentrated between the two energized phases.
-
Rotor Rotation: As the rotor rotates, the magnetic field interacts with the energized phases. The interaction induces a voltage in the stator windings, creating the back EMF.
-
Back EMF Shape: The back EMF waveform is proportional to the strength and direction of the magnetic field interacting with the stator windings. Because the magnetic field strength is constant during trapezoidal commutation, the back EMF waveform is also trapezoidal.
-
Commutation Angles: The shape of the trapezoidal back EMF is directly affected by the commutation angles. These angles determine the timing of the phase switching, which in turn influences the magnetic field strength and hence the back EMF.
Sinusoidal Commutation and Back EMF
In contrast to trapezoidal commutation, sinusoidal commutation employs a more complex switching strategy that smoothly varies the current flowing through the stator phases. This results in a sinusoidal back EMF waveform. This method achieves smoother operation and higher efficiency than trapezoidal commutation.
Why Sinusoidal Commutation Produces a Sinusoidal Back EMF:
-
Smooth Current Variation: Sinusoidal commutation involves a gradual variation in current across the stator phases, creating a rotating magnetic field with a smooth sinusoidal profile.
-
Rotating Magnetic Field: The rotating magnetic field interacts with the rotor, generating a back EMF that directly reflects the shape of the magnetic field.
-
Sinusoidal Back EMF: Since the magnetic field is sinusoidal, the back EMF waveform is also sinusoidal.
Comparison of Trapezoidal and Sinusoidal Back EMF:
| Feature | Trapezoidal Back EMF | Sinusoidal Back EMF |
|---|---|---|
| Commutation Method | Trapezoidal commutation | Sinusoidal commutation |
| Shape | Trapezoidal | Sinusoidal |
| Current Variation | Abrupt switching between phases | Smooth variation in current |
| Magnetic Field | Constant strength, concentrated between energized phases | Rotating, sinusoidal profile |
| Efficiency | Lower | Higher |
| Cost | Lower | Higher |
Conclusion:
The shape of the back EMF in a BLDC motor is directly influenced by the commutation strategy employed. Trapezoidal commutation results in a trapezoidal back EMF due to the constant magnetic field strength it produces. While this method offers simplicity and lower cost, sinusoidal commutation provides smoother operation and higher efficiency through its sinusoidal back EMF. Understanding these concepts is crucial for designing and optimizing BLDC motor systems for specific applications.